10 мар. 2023 г. · Your goal as a peer reviewer is to assess whether the paper is coherent and methodologically sound and that the author's results are ...

24 нояб. 2021 г. · ... peer review where the review comments and responses are published with the article. Try searching for some open peer reviews in you field to ...

11 мар. 2013 г. · Don't be afraid to say you don't understand; Don't automatically blame the authors when it occurs. Look for the positive aspects of the paper as ...

12 окт. 2022 г. · Tips on peer reviewing · Do the authors provide sufficient context for the current paper? · Is there a hypothesis, and if so, is it clear and ...

18 окт. 2023 г. · Terrible papers (common). If the paper is barely readable or has clear issues that make it unpublishable, I will write a polite but brief review ...

4 дек. 2020 г. · Basically, be honest. If you feel that way about a paper then say as much. Peer review is meant to be constructive, so provided you validate ...

16 июн. 2023 г. · Start with either positives, or if you don't feel positive start with 1-2 sentences just summarizing the point of the article as you see it and ...

7 янв. 2013 г. · Start off your review by summarizing the main contribution of the paper in 2-5 sentences. · If writing a negative critique, try to phrase all of ...

2 апр. 2015 г. · 14 votes, 11 comments. I have been asked to peer review a paper which has been submitted to an academic journal.

3 дек. 2022 г. · Reviewing is a thankless job but it does help your field overall. In academia we are stewards of the quality of research that impacts our field ...